WHY CAN’T SCOTTISH LABOUR SEE THERE IS A SOLUTION TO THEIR DISMAL SITUATION?

2915088014

Enjoying the Scottish Labour leadership contest? I remember when these things really meant something. This time round it could barely be more irrelevant. There is hardly anyone in Scottish Labour who will tell you that this leadership contest will determine next May’s First Minister of Scotland and even we in the SNP can palpably feel the depression in this once great party. Scottish Labour now languish at 20% in the polls and there is absolutely no sign of their diminished status being improved. They have never been further behind the SNP and the only thing that Scottish Labour have got right recently is the prediction that they haven’t reached rock bottom yet.

The thing is it doesn’t have to be so bad for Scottish Labour and a remedy to their current position is just so obvious that even I am exasperated that there is no constituency within Scottish Labour that can’t see it for themselves. Hello! It’s the constitution, comrade! How can no-one at the highest level of Scottish Labour see that the constitution remains the defining political fault line in Scottish politics and Scottish Labour are on the wrong side of it?

Scottish Labour remain defiantly opposed to meaningful constitutional change and it is simply killing them. They endearingly indulge in the forlorn hope that the constitutional debate will somehow go away and there will be a return to a pre referendum ‘normality’. And it just ain’t going to happen. There are huge unresolved issues kicking around following the referendum and Scotland is not going to get off this groove until they are satisfactorily resolved. Almost unbelievably Scottish Labour are also having a leadership contest in perhaps the most passionate anti-austerity part of the UK but have failed to tap into this groundswell precisely at the same time as the rest of the UK party have found their anti austerity voice in the campaign to elect Jeremy Corbyn. It’s as if they have conspired to find a new and unique way to increase their pointlessness.

Now I’m not saying that Scottish Labour need to adopt a position supporting independence (though that would probably provide the quickest way to its salvation) they just have to say that they are open to the idea. Even arguing for full fiscal autonomy could start to address their myriad of problems. Never before has such a disconnect existed between a political party in Scotland and the voters they need to recruit to start winning elections. Former Labour voters are several steps ahead of Scottish Labour in their ambitions and they have identified a way forward through significant constitutional change. Why do Labour think they did so badly in their former ‘Yes” heartlands? Do they really believe that a position of ‘no change’ on the constitution will somehow eventually bring these voters back? Every time a Labour leadership candidate says that this is the limit to Scotland’s constitutional ambitions they further compound this profound disconnect between their party and their former voters. Meanwhile their leadership candidates go through their almost irrelevant motions whilst no-one is listening.

Why should we in the SNP care about what happens in Scottish Labour? Well yes, we need a strong opposition to hold our government to account. But there is much more to it than that. If Labour adopted a pro-independence stance we would win the next referendum. Even if Labour adopted an agnostic position we would win. Having all the other main Scottish parties against us last time probably more than anything deprived us of a victory as we had to fight to win them over. Where Better Together was disastrous for Labour it was what was absolutely required for the No case. There could not be another Better Together if Labour were out of the equation.

And if Labour were to step aside or even get on board in the next referendum it would be good for our nation, the cause of independence but most importantly for the Labour Party too. It is just so hard to see a way back for Scottish Labour when they remain so alienated from their former voters and an independent Scotland would allow them to rebuild, reconnect and allow them the opportunity to offer a new type of leadership for a new Scotland.

Will they ever consider such a radical or bold move? Well not yet. Like an unreformed alcoholic they will continue to knock back the stuff that is destroying them before they decide on the abstinence cure. It will probably be next years Scottish election that will offer that cathartic last bottle. We should continue to encourage any voices that emerge beforehand and point out to Scottish Labour there remains a way out of their almost unsustainable doldrums. They will eventually get it and when they do – we all win.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “WHY CAN’T SCOTTISH LABOUR SEE THERE IS A SOLUTION TO THEIR DISMAL SITUATION?

  1. Pingback: WHY CAN'T SCOTTISH LABOUR SEE THERE IS A SOLUTI...

  2. David S. Briggs

    All through the referendum campaign I always thought that if Labour were pro Indy we would win it hands down. That they weren’t and actually took the Tory shilling, is to their deep and abiding disgrace. Their salvation lies in cutting themselves free of London control and becoming truly Scottish. I fear it will never happen.

    , is their abiding disgrace.

    Reply
  3. stuartlngr

    SLAB have two crippling faults which will stop them finding a way out of their self created mess. First and foremost,
    they are blinded by their hatred for the SNP who they regard are as their mortal enemy. Second, they believe their BBC life support system will also be their eventual saviour through the constant drip of propaganda.

    Reply
  4. ronald alexander mcdonald

    Interesting if Keiza is appointed as branch manager and Jeremy Corbyn wins the leadership, considering she has stated that he would be a disaster for Labour. Add the fact that Jeremy has stated he would enter into an arrangement in the future with the SNP.

    What does that tell you about Scottish Labour?

    Reply
  5. bowanarrow

    It tells me that the labour party is getting organized and sees a way to undermine the SNP in Scotland. It wouldn’t take much for the scottish labour party to rally. All they need is a self promoting left winger to win the labour leadership election and then promise the Scots what ever it takes to keep them in the union and to get all the wavering labour supporters back on side.
    After all, the typical labour voter is just looking for a safe way out, one that doesn’t take any risk.
    Better the situation you know than to take a leap of faith.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s