Just when you thought that politics couldn’t get any more exciting, the Labour Party comes along and decides on a course of internal combustion. The fratricide surrounding their leadership election is approaching unbelievable and those of us in the SNP have just been observing events in slack jawed amazement.

The Corbyn phenomenon is almost as dramatic as it was unpredicted. I don’t think anyone expected much from the UK Labour leadership contest, as the usual assorted Blairite centrists started to throw their hats into the ring. But the Labour membership is restless and they do not want ‘business as usual’. Their approach has been in response to the bland Blairite managerialism, mixed up with general anti-establishment politics. It is going to be some ride in the next few months, if as predicted, Jeremy Corbyn triumphs.

The big question is what happens next? What will be the response from the Labour leadership and most importantly what is the UK establishment likely to do?

In the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) there are only about 20 or so MPs who have declared support for Jeremy, with the rest bitterly hostile to his agenda. I don’t think there will be a split or large scale departures. The lesson of that remains forlornly marooned in the diminished ranks of the Liberal Democrats. Labour MPs will not make that mistake again.

More likely, the PLP will indulge in ‘hostile accommodation’ until they can securely dispatch of him at a time of their choosing. There will be a campaign of subtle undermining of his leadership. The PLP will gleefully present any evidence of failure with setbacks brutally exposed to try and convince the wider Labour membership of the dreadful mistake they have made and wait for the clamour to have the Blairite ‘consensus’ reinstalled again. This is a risky strategy as Labour members are just as likely to blame the MPs for any failure, and who knows, some of Jeremy’s approaches just might become popular.

That brings us to the establishment’s response. Thus far, the establishment has been conflicted in its response to the Corbyn phenomena. It has been a bit shocked at its emergence and the potential threat it presents to everything they currently enjoy. On the other hand, it has taken the view that Corbynism could never prevail and has encouraged it, hoping that the current establishment party of choice – the Tories – will become unassailable. In Scotland we got a glimpse of the establishment response when it felt that their vital interests were threatened by Scottish independence. This will be as nothing compared to the fury that will be directed at Jeremy Corbyn if there was a sense he was to prevail.

We in the SNP should carefully negotiate the new environment we will find ourselves in. At the end of the last Parliament we became the de-facto opposition and we should continue to assert ourselves as such. We will work with all who propose a progressive agenda and we will always support the interests of the Scottish people.


  1. Pingback: A HOSTILE ACCOMODATION | SNP Perth River Tay | ...

  2. Bob

    “In Scotland we got a glimpse of the establishment response when it felt that their vital interests were threatened by Scottish independence. This will be as nothing compared to the fury that will be directed at Jeremy Corbyn if there was a sense he was to prevail.”
    Quite. Which is why many SNP members. despite his not very well-informed views on Scotland, want to see him win. We can then say to his supporters, “aye weel, ye ken noo.”

  3. BampotsUtd.wordpress.com

    Its sad but corbyn and the SNP surge is a smoke screen from what is really going on and IDS is killing the lame and sick via the brutal mythical austerity the richest people in the UK have seen there wealth double over the last few year while the worker and lame have been brutally and wrongfully made to pay for the rich to have banquets while the the poor eat crumbs the torys are criminal in there actions via the Swiss bank DSL the sell of of the post office and now aha ting to sell the banks they bailed out with our cash with years more of this we should be pushing for indy2 in 18 would be good by then the cuts will be well deep and people will want change its unity in the mean time and be nice to see Jeremy help the SNP as opposition to stop the cuts and robbery of the UK assets !

  4. Bidge

    It will interesting to see what the party members do if Corbyn gets elected and the PLP undermine him. Will they have the guts to relpace sitting MP’s with candidates that more closely match their own values come the 2020 election. I think that such actions by the PLP may just push individual branches into such action. Particularly if they see it as an “Et Tu Brute” moment from the PLP and their MP in particular against Corbyn.

  5. Thomas William Dunlop

    I think the PLP shows how corrosive to democracy parliamentary sovereignty can be for a country. Once you invest too much power in that institution and the executive that rises out of it, too little power remains with the people and their concerns just get ignored and the money and influence concentrates in the parliamentarians.

Comments are closed.